Creeping Shari’a? Or Just Plain Creepy?

by Umbreen S. Bhatti

Have you heard of Zombie Muhammad? Me neither, until a few days ago, under a National Review headline declaiming “The Sharia Court of Pennsylvania.” Apparently the zombie in question made his appearance last October 11 during the annual Halloween parade in Mechanicsburg, PA, alongside other members of the Parading Atheists of Central Pennsylvania. In that parade, Zombie Muhammad, also known as Ernest Perce V, was marching alongside a Zombie Pope when “a man tried to take his 'Muhammad of Islam' sign and choked him.” Within a day, Perce uploaded video of the incident to YouTube, writing,

Oct 11 2011 in the Mechanicsburg City Parade I was attacked by a violent muslim IN AMERICA! This is proof that muslims want Shria Law in America. He attacks me to pull my beard off so he could identify me and chokes me.

I understand many will say I deserved it, but no one has the right to abridge my freedom of speech and violence is never the answer to freedom of speech. Islam is a religion of Peace? This is not the case in this video. Remember that Halloween is also all Saints Day where people wore masks and costumes to fool the spirits and ghosts. I just happened to pick a costume that scared adults too! LMAO

The other party was later identified as 46-year old Talaag Elbayomy, who was charged with harassment. The first article after the incident took place reports that the charge was dismissed by Judge Mark Martin as “basically one man's word against another's,” noting the testimony presented came from Perce, Elbayomy and Mechanicsburg Police Sgt. Brian Curtis, who received the complaint from Perce but did not witness the attack. Following the dismissal, Judge Martin lectured Perce on the First Amendment, making such statements as, according to a recording made by Perce,

In many other Muslim-speaking countries, err, excuse me, many Arabic-speaking countries, predominantly Muslim, something like this is definitely against the law there, in their society. In fact, it could be punished by death, and frequently is, in their society.

Here in our society, we have a Constitution that gives us many rights, specifically First Amendment rights. It's unfortunate that some people use the First Amendment to deliberately provoke others. I don't think that's what our forefathers intended. I think our forefathers intended to use the First Amendment so we can speak with our mind, not to piss off other people and cultures – which is what you did.

And before we knew it, “Shari'a law” had come to Pennsylvania, according to pieces reflecting the usual fear-mongering that has come to characterize any discussion of Muslims and our judicial system.

Were the judge's statements inappropriate? In this lawyer's mind, yes, as has been argued by other lawyers such as Jonathan Turley and Eugene Volokh. The First Amendment does allow us to piss off other people and cultures, in poor taste though that may be, and what happens in “Arabic-speaking countries” is hardly relevant when dispensing justice in America.  

But was the judge's disquisition a sign of what has come to be called “shari'a creep” – as the zombie at the center of this story would like us to think? Hardly, and it would have been nice to see articles addressing this issue by actually, accurately talking about what shari'a is – at a time when legislation banning the use of “shari'a law” in state courts is being proposed all over the country. “Creeping shari'a” has now become a near daily part of our political conversation, and for journalists to allow those who are most eager to insert the phrase into our discourse to go unchallenged is nothing less than irresponsible.

Umbreen Bhatti is a lawyer with experience in civil rights and constitutional law, as well as the co-founder of, a service for news readers, media producers and legal scholars seeking credible, authoritative information about Islamic law.

This entry was posted in The Scoop. Bookmark the permalink.

55 Responses to Creeping Shari’a? Or Just Plain Creepy?

  1. asfattggro3 says:

    [url=]robaxin[/url] [url=]propecia cost[/url] [url=]cephalexin[/url]

  2. asfatdb11z6 says:

    [url=]desyrel[/url] [url=]provera 10mg[/url] [url=]lisinopril[/url] [url=]amoxil[/url]

  3. asfatao4xod says:

    [url=]elavil[/url] [url=]generic tenormin[/url] [url=]cytotec 200mcg[/url] [url=]citalopram[/url]

  4. asfatnpnie7 says:

    [url=]phenergan[/url] [url=]proscar[/url] [url=]revia[/url]

  5. asfats8d9yq says:

    [url=]atenolol chlorthalidone[/url] [url=]clomid online[/url]

  6. asfatob1jzj says:

    [url=]buspar[/url] [url=]hydrochlorothiazide[/url] [url=]generic advair diskus no prescription[/url] [url=]buy inderal[/url] [url=]pfizer viagra 100mg price[/url] [url=]generic celexa[/url]

  7. asfat5rh9e9 says:

    [url=]soft tabs cialis[/url] [url=]albuterol inhaler[/url] [url=]avodart[/url] [url=]fluoxetine[/url] [url=]generic lexapro cost[/url]

  8. In addition , there are some testosterone reatment cardiovascular hazards These side effects may be a sign tat testosterone treatment is
    not for you.

  9. asfatfg9mm0 says:

    [url=]levitra[/url] [url=]buy revia[/url] [url=]eurax[/url] [url=]generic sildalis[/url] [url=]motilium[/url]

  10. asfat1shf0b says:

    [url=]nexium 40mg price[/url] [url=]tadalafil[/url] [url=]metformin prescription[/url]

  11. asfatwqvojj says:

    [url=]buy zoloft without prescription[/url] [url=]albuterol[/url] [url=]buy propranolol[/url] [url=]nolvadex[/url] [url=]albuterol[/url]

  12. asfatrfj2no says:

    [url=]tenormin anxiety[/url] [url=]lisinopril 20mg[/url] [url=]revia drug[/url] [url=]purchase viagra online without prescription[/url] [url=]tretinoin cream[/url] [url=]buy citalopram[/url] [url=]lisinopril 10mg[/url]

  13. asfatn2cbpg says:

    [url=]lisinopril[/url] [url=]buy albuterol online[/url] [url=]nolvadex[/url] [url=]tadalafil[/url] [url=]lisinopril[/url]

  14. asfatf5o6nj says:

    [url=]effexor generic[/url] [url=]prednisolone online[/url] [url=]singulair 10 mg[/url] [url=]medrol online[/url] [url=]seroquel[/url] [url=]triamterene hctz 37.5-25 mg[/url] [url=]lexapro pill[/url]

  15. asfatyl3jnx says:

    [url=]yasmin[/url] [url=]buy ventolin[/url] [url=]20 mg prozac[/url] [url=]prednisolone 5 mg[/url] [url=]generic celexa[/url] [url=]buy amitriptyline[/url]

  16. asfatd0hzfi says:

    [url=]ampicillin[/url] [url=]buy valtrex[/url] [url=]buy hydrochlorothiazide[/url] [url=]trazodone[/url] [url=]clonidine hydrochloride[/url] [url=]buy ventolin[/url] [url=]buy avodart[/url]

  17. asfat5l1ex2 says:

    [url=]buy synthroid[/url] [url=]baclofen online[/url] [url=]citalopram hbr tabs 20mg[/url] [url=]sildenafil citrate[/url] [url=]amoxil[/url] [url=]citalopram hbr tabs[/url] [url=]bentyl[/url]

  18. asfatf5asol says:

    [url=]hydrochlorothiazide[/url] [url=]albendazole[/url] [url=]propecia[/url]

  19. Additionally, there are some testosterone treatment cardiovascular risks
    These side effects may be a sign that testosterone treatment iss not for you.

  20. Testosterone supplements are typically used by men who need to increase the level of the Male hormone testosterone
    that controls functions including sexual desire and muscle increase.

  21. askn9s7ono says:

    [url=]CHEAP CIALIS[/url] [url=]GENERIC INDERAL[/url]

  22. askn7q836f says:

    [url=]celexa[/url] [url=]cost of provera[/url] [url=]benicar[/url] [url=]clindamycin 1% topical gel[/url] [url=]buy nexium[/url] [url=]proscar[/url] [url=]viagra[/url]

  23. KennethMic says:

    [url=]cephalexin[/url] [url=]diclofenac[/url] [url=]clonidine 0.1 mg[/url] [url=]nexium[/url] [url=]propecia[/url] [url=]rx viagra[/url]

  24. Robertgap says:

    [url=]eurax sale[/url]

  25. Charlesdiarl says:

    [url=]soft tabs viagra[/url] [url=]citalopram[/url] [url=]soft tabs viagra[/url] [url=]cymbalta price[/url] [url=]generic lynoral[/url] [url=]dipyridamole aspirin[/url]

  26. TracyArrax says:

    wh0cd125250 [url=]levaquin 500 mg[/url] [url=]eulexin[/url] [url=]doxycycline[/url] [url=]bupropion[/url] [url=]cialis no rx[/url] [url=]fluoxetine oral[/url] [url=]valtrex[/url] [url=]azithromycin[/url] [url=]bupropion hcl[/url]

  27. Aaronkeelt says:

    wh0cd270302 [url=]advair[/url] [url=]viagra online no prescription[/url] [url=]buy eurax[/url] [url=]bactroban[/url] [url=]fluoxetine hcl 20mg[/url] [url=]diclofenac sod[/url] [url=]tadalis sx[/url] [url=]celexa[/url]

  28. Charlesdiarl says:

    wh0cd76900 [url=]synthroid 100[/url] [url=]generic mobic[/url] [url=]crestor 10mg[/url] [url=]Lasix Online[/url]

  29. Eugeneextip says:

    wh0cd850519 [url=]gasex[/url] [url=]diclofenac[/url] [url=]lisinopril 20 mg no prescription[/url] [url=]rogaine[/url] [url=]sildalis[/url] [url=]bupropion xl 150mg[/url] [url=]viagra[/url] [url=]cleocin lotion[/url]

  30. MichaelLok says:

    wh0cd334004 [url=]viagra effekt pГҐ kvinnor[/url] [url=]get the facts[/url] [url=]acyclovir 400 mg[/url] [url=]ventolin hfa inhaler[/url] [url=]tetracycline[/url] [url=]cefadroxil[/url] [url=]view homepage[/url] [url=]prometrium[/url] [url=]wellbutrin[/url]

  31. KennethMic says:

    wh0cd769168 [url=]avalide[/url] [url=]bupropion sr 150 mg without a prescription[/url] [url=]synthroid[/url] [url=]celexa 20 mg[/url] [url=]eulexin[/url] [url=]aldactone[/url] [url=]tamoxifen[/url]

  32. Alfredswesy says:

    wh0cd607134 [url=]clonidine[/url] [url=]rimonabant online[/url] [url=]buy tadacip online[/url] [url=]site here[/url] [url=]cafergot online[/url] [url=]revia[/url] [url=]cheap cialis generic[/url] [url=]viagra[/url] [url=]albuterol online[/url]

  33. TracyArrax says:

    wh0cd943502 [url=]zestril[/url] [url=]namenda cost per pill[/url] [url=]trimox[/url] [url=]tricor tablets[/url]

  34. Aaronkeelt says:

    wh0cd448446 [url=]yasmin birth control[/url]

  35. Eugeneextip says:

    wh0cd547368 [url=]tadacip[/url] [url=]buy lisinopril[/url] [url=]azithromycin 500mg treatment[/url]

  36. I seriously love your website.. Pleasant colors & theme.
    Did you make this website yourself? Please reply back
    as I’m looking to create my own website and want to learn where you got this from or what the theme is called.
    Appreciate it!

  37. The number of guests at dinner should not be less than the number of the Graces nor exceed that of the Muses, i.e., it should begin with three and stop at nine.

  38. Ich bin gerade zufaellig auf Ihrer Seite gelandet (war auf der Suche nach einer anderen Homepage). Ich moechte diese websiete nicht verlassen, ohne Dir ein Lob zu dieser klar strukturierten und schick designten Seite zu hinterlassen!
    atletico madrid tröja

  39. Thanks for sharing such a nice thinking, post is pleasant,
    thats why i have read it completely

  40. Being trite isn’t a concern of I just write what comes to If it’s trite, I guess it’s Don’t really

  41. water moon says:

    Be aware of wonder. Live a balanced life–learn some and think some and draw and paint and sing and dance and play and work every day some.

  42. I cannot thank you enough for the article post.Thanks Again. Great.

  43. quick cash loans direct lender payday loans cash advance [url=]cash advance[/url]

  44. essay writing paper writing essay writing [url=]argument essay[/url]

  45. payday loans direct lenders only cash loans payday loans online [url=]loan[/url]

  46. college essay tutors research essay college essay 2018 [url=]write my research paper[/url]

  47. Loan Cash says:

    unsecured loans unsecured loans unsecured loans [url=]best debt consolidation loans approved by bbb[/url]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.